SHELL
Soft parts: foot usually white, rarely bright orange
Similar species/lookalikes: With all its very variable characteristics, this taxon can be a great imitator. Average size, shell thickness and color are extremely variable depending on water quality and hardness of habitat. Live adults can especially be easily be confused with flutedshell specimens with subtle or absent posterior slope corrugations, as both taxons often share the same habitats. Weathered shells of E. complanata that have lost their purple nacre color can be readily identified by the well developed lateral teeth, which are lacking in L. costata. Those same criteria can be applied to differentiate from the Eastern pearlshell, Margaritifera margaritifera, but this taxon is rarely found in the same habitat as E. complanata.
Most confusing, in both live and dead state, when compared with the two other Canadian members of the genus, E. crassidens and E. dilatata, due to it's extremely variable shell length and morphology, a trait also shared to a lesser extent by these other two taxons. however, both of these taxons usually have older ventral growth lines at an angle with more recent ones, whereas Eastern Elliptios usually show proportional, harmonious growth lines throughout life, causing ventral margin lines to be relatively parallel, not angled.
A full spectrum of inter-grades occurring in some localities where these taxons coexist makes reliable identification challenging at best.
Future genetic studies are needed to help resolve this taxonomic morass.