Heads up: Some or all of the identifications affected by this split may have been replaced with identifications of Anarhynchus. This happens when we can't automatically assign an identification to one of the output taxa. Review identifications of Charadrius mongolus 4785

Taxonomic Split 133048 (Committed on 10-31-2023)

eBird/Clements Checklist v2023 (Citation)
Added by birdwhisperer on October 29, 2023 11:35 PM | Committed by birdwhisperer on October 31, 2023
split into

Comments

Hi @birdwhisperer don't you think it would be better to first switch C. mongolus to A. mongolus?
This way, the uncertainly ID'd specimens would still be under Anarhynchus, unless I'm mistaken?

EDIT: I checked the ID analysis tool and it seems that everything will end up being Anarhynchus. All is good then :)

Posted by donalddavesne 6 months ago

@donalddavesne @rjq Ok, we can discuss committing this now. This one is stuff split, due to the ambiguous nature of wintering range and vagrancy, so take a moment to review and if it all looks good...

Here's what the analyses say right now:

Total: 2379 obs
Tibetan: 103 obs
Siberian: 110 obs
Outside Ranges: 81 obs
Overlap Ranges: 107 obs

Posted by birdwhisperer 6 months ago

Checking the "outside ranges" I found a few places that weren't in the atlas, like Shanghai and Macao.
Let's review these several times before validating

Posted by donalddavesne 6 months ago

Also what about NE China and Mongolia? Shouldn't that be mongolus as well?

Posted by donalddavesne 6 months ago

These are the ebird overlap areas: For the moment, records in the following regions have been unchanged by eBird Central (although some may be refined in the coming weeks with feedback from local experts): Mongolia, most of China (except Xizang and Qinhai = Tibetan and the coast from Fujian north = Siberian); note that coastal records from Guangdong south likely involve Siberian primarily, Macao and Hong Kong, Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos, Borneo, Sulawesi, Lesser Sundas, Cocos and Keeling Islands.

Posted by rjq 6 months ago

So @rjq would you validate the switch? Sounds fine to me, but I'm neither an expert on these birds nor an experienced validator.

Posted by donalddavesne 6 months ago

Have adjusted the atlases according to the eBird text. I think it’s OK to commit now

Posted by rjq 6 months ago

Sounds good to me!

Posted by donalddavesne 6 months ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments