Taxonomic Swap 105596 (Committed on 2022-02-18)

unknown
Yes
Added by tonykris on February 18, 2022 12:53 PM | Committed by tonykris on February 18, 2022
replaced with

Comments

@tonykris Why was this change made? Subgenus Lyceana is valid in the taxonomic authority:

https://butterfliesofamerica.com/US-Can-Cat.htm

Remember that taxonomic changes like this must be explained and cite a source. Your change lacks both.

Posted by treichard over 2 years ago

Why does the subgenus lycaena exist twice (one inactive, one active)?
https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/522624-Lycaena
https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/1360268-Lycaena

Posted by schoenitz over 2 years ago

The latter was created today by @tonykris. @tonykris would you mind explaining what has happened? If there's a mistake I'm sure we can help sort it out.

Posted by matthewvosper over 2 years ago

@treichard @schoenitz @matthewvosper I'm confused about the Butterflies of America Species page showing the genus Tharsalea. But when I click into the genus Tharsalea, all species in the genus Tharsalea are represented as Lycaena.
E.g. Lycaena xanthoides : https://butterfliesofamerica.com/t/Lycaena_xanthoides_a.htm

Posted by tonykris over 2 years ago

I'm confused because whichever perception of mine I click I always end up with the blue glazier.

Posted by anja_spin over 2 years ago

The catalog page was updated earlier this month. Other pages may still need an update to match.

This and related taxon changes still need an explanation and cited source. This should have been included before the changes were committed. This current change looks like an error, but if it is not due to other related changes, it needs to be explained and cited.

Posted by treichard over 2 years ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments